(A Term Paper Presented in a Seminar on Sexual Abuse, Social Discrimination and Economic Exploitation organised by Vaiphei Christian Fellowship, Delhi at Murnika, New Delhi July 24, 2010 Presented by Madhu Chandra)
First they came for the Jews and I did not speak out because I was not a Jew. Then they came for the Communists and I did not speak out because I was not a Communist. Then they came for the trade unionists and I did not speak out because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for me and there was no one left to speak out for me. – Martin Niemöller.
First sexual abuse, social discrimination and economic exploitation happened to the people from Nagaland, I did not speak out because I was not a Naga. Then it happened to the people from Manipur, I did not speak out because I was not a Manipuri. Then it happened to the people from Mizoram, I did not speak out because I was not a Mizo. Then it happened to the people from Arunachal Pradesh, I did not speak out because I was not an Arunachalese. Then it happened to me, there was not one left to speak out for me. — anonymous response
Unprecedented Racial Discrimination
Delhi police, Delhi and Union Governments, civil societies and intellectuals refused to accept the racial discrimination faced by the people from North East India, who are working, studying and living in Delhi and National Capital Regions (NCR). Refusal and denial to accept the struggles faced by the people from North East India by the concerned government and police forces continued for last five years until the killing of 19-years-old Tangkhul girl from Manipur in last October at Murnika by IIT Ph. D. student. Whole nation cried when Shilpa Shetty in Celebrity of Big Brother faced racial abuse at London in 2007 and Indians at Australia recently but kept silence spectator when it happened to its own people from North East India. Non-acceptance and denial of the racial discrimination faced by the people from North East India by the law enforcement agencies and government authorities is the additional form of racial discrimination. Enough incidents had happened in last six years at Delhi and NCR, probably begun with heinous crime of gang rape of a girl from Mizoram in a moving car at Dhuala Kuan in 2005, whose verdict came after four years with 14 years of imprisonment. North East Support Centre & Helpline established in 2008, conducted two pilot studies one in 2008, based on media reporting on sexual abuse in national capital, where almost 50% cases were happened to the girls from North East India. Second pilot study conducted in 2009, reveals 86% of North East people living have said that they are facing racial discrimination in various forms like, sexual abuse, physical attacks, vulgar remarks, social profiling and economic exploitation. These are documented and reported in national news papers and national televisions, from which, law enforcement agencies and government machineries should have understood the plights faced by the people of North East India in Delhi and NCR.
Double blow of racial discrimination came when the law enforcement agency, particularly of Delhi police and NCR, refused, denied and delayed to entertain the cases filed by victims from North East India. If the police forces, would have avoided the social profiling in performing their duties, the issue of sexual abuse, racial discrimination and economic exploitation faced by the people from North East India would have, long time, prevented. Due to the discrimination by the law enforcement agencies, the plight of racial discrimination remained unprecedented till these days. 2009 went up with highest record of violence against the people from North East India in Delhi and NCR. Nothing to celebrate this year with just six cases so far because, the number crime in 2009 went up only after September. Anything could happen at any time because there still exist unprecedented violence against the people from North East India.
Racial Discrimination on Record
|Nature of Cases||Total||2009||2010||2005-08||FIR||No FIR|
|Rent Non Refund||2||1||1||0||2|
After much has happened, Delhi Police issued a Zero Tolerance policy in respect of crime against women including the violence faced by the people from North East India. Delhi police acted better at least in registering the complaints and yet to see their honesty in handling the cases to punish the perpetrators and give justice to the victims. A white paper must be given on how police has handled the cases pending in police stations on the cases related to the racial discrimination faced by the people from North East India.
Nature of Racial Discrimination Faced by North East People
It is sexual abuse, social profiling and economic exploitation. Whenever and wherever any attack happens to the people of North East India, it is deeply connection with gender-based discrimination, social connotation which affected the economic opportunities for the people of North East India in Delhi and NCR. Racial discrimination is treating people differently through a process of social division into categories not necessarily related to races. The plight faced by people from North East India has been in the form of social profiling. It is a crime as per Article 15 of Indian Constitution. Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth. (1) The State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them. Blacks suffered apartheid for years and whole world condemns it. UN has condemned Indias caste system and termed it worse than racism. The Racism faced by North East India is definitely outcome of caste system. To fight racism, one can not ignore the apartheid of casteism existed among Indian societies. Whenever sexual abuse and racial attack happens, the general public has social profiled the people from North East India on the bases of different culture, different look and different geographical background. Social profiling is against the ethos of Indias acclaim of unity in diversity. Social profiling will distance the communities from one another. Economic exploitation is one of the immediate effects suffer from racial discrimination, particularly to young working boys and girls from North East India. Two sisters who where sexually abused by twenty men in Gandhi Vihar in January, 2008 had to close her cyber café through which, she supported her brother and sister who were pursuing for further studies. She could not relocate and start her business any more in Delhi and had to pack and go back home. Like her, most of the victims suffer sexual abused in their offices had to quit from job.
What are the Root Causes?
Hundred times have been asked this question, in deed many attempted to put into our mouths to blame North East girls for their life style. Many civil societies and law enforcement agencies even said this, in stead of condemning the crime. Social profiling the people from North East India is the main root causes of sexual abuse, social discrimination and economic exploitation. Social profiling has caused North East girls as vulnerable in the eyes of perpetrators. The notion of social profiling the opinion formed upon ones appearance, culture and levelling everyone equal with some opinions formed upon some experiences. Once a community is socially profiled, ones economic, social, educational and professional status does not matter and everyone is looked upon socially and racially with low image. Next to social profiling is the mind-set of people on North East communities which has become a major cause of sexual abuse, social discrimination and economic exploitation. A mindset of social profiling is that the people from North East India are strangers, free culture, cheap and do anything one likes, you can get free. Social profiling is also seen in the attitudes of local police when they insult, deceive, ignore and deny the complaints and connived with perpetrators in many cases.
How do we handle this?
Never forget Niemollers poem. Stand up when it happens to person next to you, irrespective of race, religion and region. It is your rights to fight when it happens to you, but never take the law into your hand. Stay connected with your student bodies, community leaders and churches, if you are a Christian because most of the North East communities have their own churches in Delhi. Street sexual harassment may be casually referred to as eve teasing but it is a crime under sections 354 and section 509 of the Indian Penal Code. Section 354: Assault or criminal force used to outrage the modesty of a woman. Penalty of two years imprisonment and/or a fine. Section 509: Words, gestures, sounds, exhibition of objects that intrude on the privacy and are intended to outrage the modesty of a woman. Penalty of one year of imprisonment and/or a fine. If you have been harassed on the street and want to file a police complaint, you can go to the nearest police station and file a First Information Report (FIR). It is your right to file an FIR. If you need help, call one of women’s helplines given in this booklet.
How to File First Information Report
FIR or First Information Report is the information about commission of an offence given to a police officer by the first informant. It initiates the criminal proceedings. To file an FIR, one has to go to the police station within the jurisdiction of which the cause of action arose or the offence took place. Every piece of information relating to the commission of offence is to be given to the officer in-charge of the police station. If it is given orally to the officer, he shall reduce it to writing and read it over to the informant to confirm and verify the details. Every such information has to be signed by the informant after which it is required to be recorded by the officer in a book maintained for this purpose as prescribed by the State Government. The informant is entitled to receive a copy of the FIR free of cost. If the officer in-charge of the police station refuses to record the information, you can send the substance of such information, in writing and by post to the Superintendent of Police (SP) concerned. The SP is required to start the investigation himself or direct any other officer subordinate to him to start the investigation.
NOTE: When you file a FIR, be very specific. Dont forget to take a copy of the FIR. One is not required by law to give an affidavit.
What You Can Do
Protest if you are harassed. Shout loudly at the harasser and attract the attention of others. Speak up if you see someone else being harassed. Shout at the harasser and ask others around to protest as well. Call police helpline, give details of the incident and place. File a police complaint when you are harassed. Take help from friends, study leaders and community leaders. Call NE Helpline, you will be guided and follow the instruction. For more information, please visit our website www.nehelpline.net.
9716004939, 9818314146, 9810455901
Madhu Chandra is a research scholar, human rights activist and missionary based at New Delhi, working as Public Relation Officer of All India Christian Council, Founder and Spokes Person of North East Support Centre & Helpline and National Secretary of All India Confederation of SC/ST Organisations.
i really like your report and specific focus on the root cause of this tension.once we know the root cause,its the foundation of future plans and struggle.social profilling is the issue and life style is another reason for discrimination.central government should raise attention to the north eastern people by allotting them seperate colony(specially for the north east) and supporting them through community welfare in the capital.it is so pathetic to see north east people living standard in delhi,they are taking room on rent which is always higher for chingkis , food,ration,transportation all are double for norhteast people because owners think we have more money. social attitude can improve if government will help underprivileged to raise standards.
because of few mischief north east girl is not the big issue or root cause,root cause is lack of central governement support for the northeast people in delhi.every year, delhi governement sell a house and apartments which are always at reasonable rates but norht east cant purchase this due to fund shortage.theirfore,it is very best to have a seperate community in delhi and stay with unified force.seven sister state govt should buy a place speciallly for northeast people in delhi and can stay without friction of diferent culture and language.see muslims and hindu’s who despite thousand years of staying together cant stay together today .you see jama masjid is dominated by muslims and chandni chowk by the particular comunity and karol bagh again another community.very few are exceptional.
india is a nation of multiculture and multilingual, so we must approach central government for upgradation and special attention.also to the state government.